In the world of pop entertainment, visuals are inseparable from performance. P-Pop idols are expected not only to sing and dance flawlessly, but also to embody ever-changing standards of beauty. While this helps create a polished industry, it also sets up impossible expectations that can undermine talent.

In the Philippines, Taglish is everyday life. It’s how Filipinos text, chat, and talk in classrooms, offices, and online spaces. Instead of being forced, it’s an instinctive rhythm of communication that reflects a bilingual society.

Even SB19, now celebrated as trailblazers of P-Pop, weren’t immune to these pressures. At the start of their career, they were criticized harshly—not for their music, but for their looks. Instead of being judged by their artistry, they were picked apart based on appearances, with some online trolls calling them visual holes. Stell put this frustration into words perfectly: he came out to show his talent, but people kept focusing on visuals. Looking at their presscon photos from their debut, all the ‘visual hole’ criticisms are way overblown. They were cute, good-looking guys, just still growing into their looks and style!

PHOTO FROM PEP.PH 

Later, when the group found ways to enhance their natural features through aesthetic procedures, styling, and grooming, critics simply found new ways to attack them. Even Justin wasn’t spared. His nose was doubted to be natural, with some accusing him of having had work done. Fans were quick to defend him, sharing childhood photos and even family pictures as “receipts,” showing that his sharp features were a product of genetics, not the operating table (not that there’s anything wrong with enhancements, either).

This reflects the no-win situation many idols find themselves in. They’re expected to be beautiful, but at the same time, they’re pressured to look “natural.” Any sign of enhancement is judged, yet failing to meet impossible beauty standards is criticized just as harshly.

This reflects the no-win situation many idols find themselves in. They’re expected to be beautiful, but at the same time, they’re pressured to look “natural.” Any sign of enhancement is judged, yet failing to meet impossible beauty standards is criticized just as harshly.

Beauty ideals in the Philippines mirror those in many Asian countries, where fairer skin, a high nose bridge, and refined features are often celebrated. Whitening products dominate the market, reinforcing these traditional standards.

Kyler Chua (HORI7ON) embodies this standard —ranking #21 on TC Candler’s 2024 list of the 100 Most Handsome Faces. With his sharp jawline, expressive eyes, and effortlessly polished visuals, Kyler embodies the “idol look” that often gets international attention. His charm strikes a balance between boy-next-door approachability and high-fashion elegance, making him one of the most talked-about rising stars in P-Pop. But Filipino beauty ideals are also diverse. Many fans celebrate moreno beauty—tanned skin that reflects the nation’s sun-kissed heritage. For men, there’s the timeless “TDH” archetype: tall, dark, and handsome. Ken (Felip) of SB19 embodies this perfectly, with his unique look contributing to his strong mass appeal.

For women, the conversation often revolves around morena vs. mestiza beauty. Girl groups like BINI are a great example of how P-Pop challenges and reshapes these ideals. Members like Aiah and Colet proudly represent morena beauty, earning admiration from fans who see themselves reflected in them. At the same time, other members embody the more conventional fair-skinned standard, creating a group that shows how beauty in the Philippines is not one-dimensional.

PHOTO FROM BINI’S INSTAGRAM PAGE

While some idols are criticized for not fitting conventional beauty standards, others face the opposite bias. Artists who are considered conventionally attractive often have their talent underestimated, as if their success comes from looks alone. This ‘too handsome’ or ‘too pretty’ stereotype dismisses the years of training, discipline, and creativity that define P-Pop idols. SB19’s Justin has been a victim of this misconception, as many fail to recognize the effort he puts in both in front of and behind the camera.

These struggles aren’t confined to the Philippines. K-Pop idols are frequently scrutinized for being either “too plain” or “too polished.” International stars face the same relentless commentary on age, weight, or cosmetic choices. Across industries, celebrities walk a fine line—expected to look perfect, yet often condemned for the very efforts they take to meet those expectations.

At its core, this reveals a cultural obsession with beauty that often overshadows artistry. While visuals may catch attention, it is music, performance, and connection with fans that endure. P-Pop’s growth proves that audiences are learning to see beyond appearances, embracing talent, authenticity, and cultural pride.

As Stell’s words remind us, talent should never take a backseat to appearance. After all, it’s the art—not the shade of skin or the symmetry of features—that leaves the most lasting legacy.